When it comes time to pick the best water pump for your enlargement needs, there are several great options to choose from.

Two of my personal favorites are the Bathmate series as well as the Penomet. While both options can produce some amazing gains, there are some subtle differences that may make one work better for you when compared to the other.

I’ve personally put both to the test (both provide an awesome pump), and while I’d recommend giving either one a try, let’s take a closer look at the Penomet and Bathmate models, so you can officially decide which one will be your best fit.

Penomet vs Bathmate: Features and Model Head-to-Head

1. Penomet’s Best Features and Model Options

the penomet premium package

The Penomet Hydropump series is designed to be used with water. This makes it different from the traditional air or vacuum pumps that you may be more used to seeing.

Hydropumps give a more equal volume and pressure, so Penomet claims that their pump will give more equal gains, where vacuum pumps may enlarge one area of the penis, but not others.

  • 5 Interchangeable Gaiters

a set of penomet gaiters

One of the best features that sets Penomet apart from the competition is their 5 interchangeable gaiters. These give you the option of slowly and safely increasing the pressure, so you can build up more pressure over time as your body adjusts to your pumping schedule.

Penomet says their gaiter system can help you get gains up to 65% quicker when compared to using other pumps that have a fixed gaiter system.

Penomet Model Options

When it comes time to buy your Penomet, you currently have three model options to choose from. This gives you a variety of pricing points and gaiter options to meet your needs.

  • Penoment Hydropump Premium 

With this package you get all five gaiters, as well as the Penomet 4.0 Hydropump, a carrying case, a digital exercise guidebook, a printed instruction manual, a 60 day satisfaction guarantee, plus a 3 year warranty. It’s the best package Penomet currently offers.

  • Penomet Hydropump Extra

This package gives you access to three gaiters, plus the digital and printed guidebooks and the 3 year warranty.

  • Penomet Hydropump Standard

This is the most affordable option Penomet offers. It only includes their Force 70 Gaiter, so if you’re looking for max gains, you may want to consider one of their other packages. You do, however, get access to both guide books, the money back guarantee, and the 3 year warranty.

Tips for Picking the Right Penomet Package for You

Deciding between the Penomet packages will come down to a couple of key factors:

  • What’s Your Budget?
  • What Kind of Gains Do You Hope to See?

If budget is the biggest concern, then start with the Standard Package. If your gains are the most important factor, then opt for the Premium Package, so you can get access to their full assortment of gaiters.

2. Bathmate’s Best Features and Model Options

the bathmate hydroxtreme7

Bathmate is another water-based pump, and is considered by many to be one of the best in the business. They definitely give Penomet a run for their money, and have an awesome collection of pumps to pick from. Like Penomet, there are a variety of pricing points to choose from.

No matter what size you’re currently sitting at, they should have a great option to help get you started.

  • HydroXtreme7 Offers Maximum Pumping Power

If you’re looking for the ultimate pump, then the HydroXtreme7 is the place to start. Much like the five gaiter system that Penomet offers, the HydroXtreme provides an opportunity to start slowly, and then max out your pumps for max gains.

They’ve dubbed it their “expert choice for penis pumping,” but we’d say it’s a great option for beginners too – just don’t over do it if you’re new to pumping. Start out slowly and then build up over time to build up those lasting gains.

Bathmate Model Options

the full line of Bathmate models

Bathmate has multiple models and sizing options to pick from, which makes them a perfect fit for beginners all the way up to seasoned pumpers. They also have a variety of pricing points as well, so if you’re trying to keep it as cheap as possible, they have some great options to consider. Here’s a quick look at the models they currently offer:

  • Hydro7 Series

Bathmate’s Hydro7 Series is perfect for beginners or those on a limited budget. This is the very first collection of hydro pumps that Bathmate brought to market, and provide some awesome value for the money.

They currently offer one model in the Hydro7 series which Bathmate says is a great choice for guys who are packing between 5 and 7 inches when fully hard.

  • HydroMax Series

The HydrowMax series gives you access to one of Bathmate’s best variety of size options. They currently have HydroMax’s for erection lengths ranging from 3 inches all the way up to 9 inches.

The HydroMax is the best-selling pump in the world, and that’s because it provides 35% more power than their standard Hydropump.

In fact, it works so well Bathmate reports that 92% of Hydromax customers report being satisfied with the performance or their pump.

  • HydroXtreme Series

The HydroXtreme’s are the most powerful pumps that Bathmate offers, and are the ultimate choice for penis improvement. The HydroXtreme is their most advanced hydropump to date and provides maximum pressure for intense gains.

If you’re looking for Bathmate’s best-of-the-best, then the HydroXtreme is where you’ll want to start.

Like the HydroMax’s they have a nice range of sizes starting at 3 inches, and going all the way up to 11 inches.

Tips for Picking the Right Bathmate Package for You

Again, when it comes time to pick the perfect pump it’ll come down to a few key factors:

  • Your Budget
  • Your Size
  • How Much Pumping Power You Want

If budget is an issue, Bathmate has several great options for getting you started. Another important thing to consider with Bathmate is that they have models starting as small as three inches within the HydroMax and HydroXtreme series. Or if you’re open the larger end of things, the HydroExtreme can accommodate up to an 11 inch hog. Whoa.

We encourage you to take a look at all of their models at the Bathmate website so you can get a good feel for which option is going to be your best fit.

Results Comparison: Will Penomet or Bathmate Get You Bigger?

While neither Bathmate or Penomet is going to guarantee that you’ll see permanent gains, they both are willing to stand behind their products, and offer generous satisfaction guarantees. That means if you’re not happy with either of their products within a certain time frame, you can reach out to them about getting your money back.

That said, both companies shared some impressive results that their customers reported.

Bathmate Length and Girth Gains

According to Bathmate, they sent out a survey in 2020 to 12,000 of their customers, and the feedback was pretty extraordinary.

Of those respondents, 81% of users reported either longer or better erections. And of those, more than 70% said their erections were both better and longer, with another 79% reporting that Bathmate and given them more confidence.

You can read more super impressive results at the Bathmate website.

Penomet Length and Girth Gains

Penomet proudly shares some customers testimonials at their website as well, and there are some pretty impressive results reported. While we encourage you to read them all, Kemlan’s review especially stood out:

“I need to keep this short and sweet because I truly believe that’s the only way anybody can accurately describe this… this… I don’t know mean to sound cliche, but this life changing product. I originally purchased this to suprise my girlfriend. Much to her dismay I’ve found myself enjoying my time with ME almost as much as my time with HER. Take my word for it. If you use this even somewhat frequently, the results will below (both of you) away.”

Read many more customer testimonials at the Penomet website.

Price Compare: Is Penomet or Bathmate Cheaper?

Both Penomet and Bathmate offer a similar price range, with Bathmate having more overall options and pricing points to pick from. Here’s a quick pricing breakdown:

Penomet Price Range

  • Penomet’s Current Price Range is $127 to $297
  • *Prices current at the time of publication – see most up-to-date pricing at the Penomet website

Bathmate Price Range

  • Bathmate’s Current Price Range is $110 to $399
  • *Prices current at the time of publication – see most up-to-date pricing at the Bathmate website

Summary: Final Tips for Picking Your Perfect Hydropump

While some would say it’s a toss up between Penomet and Bathmate, there a few deciding factors that may push you in one direction over the other. Here are a few final factors to consider which pump is best for you:

You Should Pick Penomet if…

  • You want an affordable entry-point
  • You like their money-back guarantee
  • You want multiple gaiters to gradually increase the pump
  • You want to see results within as little as 15 minutes of ussage

You Should Pick Bathmate if….

  • You want the cheaper starting point
  • You’re on the smaller or larger end of things – options from 3 to 11 inches
  • You want the larger selection of pumps
  • You want the maximum pump that the HydroXtreme provides